Anjuan Simmons Technology Translator

11Jun/083

The New Negro Problem

In 1944, Swedish economist Gunnar Myrdal published a study called An American Dilemma: The Negro Problem and Modern Democracy.  In this study, Myrdal claimed that white people, in general, want to see black people (then called 'Negros', although this term is usually inappropriate to use today) disappear from America.  This is due to the perception by whites that blacks are inferior in every way.  Without earning the benefits of having them as slaves, white people saw no use for black people in America.

However, Myrdal believed that the "the Negro problem" was a "white man's problem".  This is due to the fact that white people, through enslavement and institutionalized racism, were responsible for the low estate of black people.  Only by using the privileges that the social and economic structure of America gave to whites could blacks be elevated.  Once blacks were able to improve their situation, then white people could look at them favorably and cease to see them as inferiors, thus leading to improved racial harmony.

I suggest that there is a "new" Negro problem.  As black people have improved their situation, white people see fewer and fewer reasons to accept the problems (social, economic, health, etc.) that have historically plagued the African American population of this country. Furthermore, black people who have been successful, such as athletes, actors, politicians, etc., give the impression to other races that there is no longer a need to pay special attention to racism.  Since many blacks have "made it", then the struggle for racial equality must be over.

This unprecedented level of success in the African American community, particularly in the ascension of Barack Obama, is a potential problem because there are many black people who still struggle with the many damaging legacies of slavery.  Without a focus on their needs, then a large segment of the African American population will continue to suffer from racist attitudes directed at them from blacks as well as whites.  While toiling in darkness, their problems will be ironically hidden by the blinding lights of black luminaries such as Oprah Winfry and Dick Parsons.

The solution to this problem is for successful black people to be ever vigilant in the defense of those African Americans who still have not found success either through racism, ignorance, or simply bad luck.  Also, white people need to understand that the crippling effects of centuries of racism cannot be reversed by the relative new phenomena of equality and inclusion.  Only then can the appropriate assistance (educational, economic, and social) be extended by those who have often been denied the American Dream.  I am not calling for eternal welfare for African Americans, but I am calling for help for black people who have a desire to improve their situation but simply cannot due to the realities of our nation's history.  As Myrdal postulated, the improvement of the state of African Americans will help all Americans free themselves of the historical negative view of blacks.

Filed under: Opinion Leave a comment
  • Uh got to get back wit ya on that. but uh I'll try to give an answer

    but blacks being the white man's problem or burden (uh one of these) Is this given to all blacks that are huuuh under the social ecomomic/ or financial line, that is a burden on society because of A crime, because they cannot support themsellves properly on meager salaries, drug use behavior because of course if your meager salary cannot sustain you, people usually sell dope to make money, hey got to have a roof over your head, and money used to house and clothe brothers who have been incarcerated. been going on for years,
    but to educate, and empower, and motivate, a a large majority of a race takes time, and do we actually have the humaity and love to do it. I agree on what you said about black should take the reins and help out our fellow black man, but how many blacks will turn the white man's burden into the upper to middle class black man's burder or black womens burden. and who will fund these great educators and teachers to help out those who have lost their way, maybe in a perfect world, but hey I would like for that to come true to. I feel it is not to late.
  • Joe,
    Thanks for leaving a comment on my blog.

    I would like to better understand your position. You say that you don't know any blacks that have interest or concern for their families. How many black people do you know? I know many black people that have a great amount of interest and concern for their families. Conversely, I also know several white people who have very little interest or concern for their families. This is not a matter of skin color. It is a matter of who the person is.

    Are you denying that centuries of slavery have had a tremendously crippling effect on those who descended from slaves? Are you descended from slaves?

    What African states have education, employment, criminal, and IQ levels similar to African Americans?

    What is your explanation for what you call low black achievement?
  • Joe
    Blacks I know don't have anything like the interest or concern for their families that whites and especially asians do, so the idea they are 'held back' by psychic trauma 'cos of injustices suffered by ancestors is crazy.... Then there's every other ethnic group who's overcame historic injustice without requiring the special favors blacks need.... Then there's EVERY other country in the world where the special racial history of America doesn't apply - yet the racial profiles in education , employment, criminality and IQ match America's patterns - even majority black African states.

    You're dismissing the most obvious, parsimonious explanation for low black achievement in measures in civility. If you want to blame stereotypes - show the stereotypes aren't true.
blog comments powered by Disqus
The New Negro Problem « Anjuan Simmons

Anjuan Simmons Technology Translator